Monday, October 26, 2015

Top 10 Ski Area Microclimates

A microclimate refers to the unique meteorological conditions that occur at a given location or area.  Mountainous regions tend to produce a plethora of microclimates due to the strong influence that complex terrain has on meteorology.  Below are my top-10 U.S. ski-area microclimates, plus some honorable mentions, based on remarkable aspects of the snowfall characteristics compared to the surrounding area or region.

10. Wolf Creek Pass, CO

Colorado is not especially snowy, but Wolf Creek Pass is the exception to the rule.  At an altitude of 10,640 feet, the long-term observing site at Wolf Creek Pass has an average annual snowfall of 435 inches, highest in the state.  In addition, Wolf Creek Pass is well situated to be pounded in warm storms with southwesterly flow, resulting in snow with a higher average water content than found elsewhere in Colorado [10.3% (Judson and Doesken 2000)].

9. Gore Mountain, NY

Not all microclimates are good for skiing.  The problem at Gore is that it is too far east to get much lake effect and a bit to far northwest to receive as much nor'easter snow as the mountains of New England.  C'est la vie.

Source: Northeast Regional Climate Center
8. Mt. Bohemia, MI

Mt. Bohemia might be the most geographically isolated ski area in the contiguous United States.  It's on the Keweenaw Peninsula, about as far north as you can get on the UP of Michigan and nearly surrounded by Lake Superior.

Source: Google Maps
You want lake effect?  Mt. Bohemia is the place.  The resort claims an average snowfall of 273 inches and, although it's difficult to confirm this given a paucity of long-range observing sites in the area, it's clearly the snowiest ski area in the midwest.  And it's bloody cold too.  Deep powder, certain frostbite, what are you waiting for?

7. Jay Peak, VT

In 2008, Trevor Alcott and I wrote a paper for the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society entitled Secrets of the Greatest Snow on Earth (I ultimately used the article as a springboard for my book of the same title).  When in review, one of the anonymous reviewers took great offense that we did not include Jay Peak in the analysis.  Fair enough.  Jay does especially well in northwesterly flow thanks to the orientation of the mountains of northern Vermont and a lack of substantial upstream terrain.  There are other northern Vermont ski areas benefit from these characteristics, but perhaps not to the extent of Jay Peak.  Plus the Jay Peak powder cult has threatened me enough that I no longer question the power of the Jay Peak cloud.

6. Alyeska, AK

Alyeska rises above the Turnagain Arm just east of Anchorage and has a base elevation of only 250 feet.  Due to the formidable nature of the Chugach Mountains and the maritime nature of the region, it probably has the largest snowfall gradient with altitude of any major resort in the United States, which results from both the increase in precipitation with altitude and the increase in the fraction of precipitation that falls as snow.  Resort statistics suggest a 208" mean snowfall at the base and a 512" mean snowfall at mid mountain (~1400 feet).  That staggering increase is characteristic of coastal Alaska, but where else do you find a major ski area cutting through it?

5. Snow Ridge, NY


In my view, Snow Ridge has the best quality natural snowfall in the northeast United States.  The area reports a very believable average snowfall of 230 inches, most of which is lake effect generated by Lake Ontario.  Even my snow-snobby students enjoyed a powder day there when we were working on the Tug Hill Plateau a couple of years ago.


4. Mammoth Mountain, CA

Mammoth Mountain gets an absolutely sick amount of snow for the eastern Sierra.  If you want to know why, look at the map below.  Note how big and broad the Sierra are to the north of Mammoth, and how big and broad the Sierra are to the south of Mammoth.  Then look at how the San Joaquin River cuts a path right to Mammoth Mountain's doorstep.  As a result, Sierra storms dump less load before hitting Mammoth, and Mammoth gets an unusual amount of snow for it's extreme eastern location.

Source: Google Maps
Meteorologists call the depletion of atmospheric water vapor by precipitation airmass transformation.  An interesting aspect of atmospheric water vapor is a very small fraction of it contains hydrogen isotopes that are relatively heavy (they have one proton and one neutron instead of just a proton).  Water vapor molecules that contain this heavier hydrogen isotope, known as deuterium, tend to condense more readily and rain out as an airmass pushes inland.  As a result, the snowpack in the eastern Sierra tends to be somewhat depleted of deuterium, except at one place.  Mammoth.

The map below is an oldie but a goodie and shows an analysis of deuterium in the Sierra snowpack.  Note the nose of higher values at Mammoth, illustrating that airmasses impinging on Mammoth Mountain have experienced less transformation and water vapor depletion that those that have traverse broader, higher topography to the north and south.

Ratio of deuterium to hydrogen (D/H) in Sierra snow expressed as a per mil
 departure from that found in standard ocean water (Friedman and Smith 1970).
3. Alta/Snowbird, UT

It's a bit self-serving to put Alta/Snowbird at #3 on this list, but I've yet to find an area in the contiguous United States with a better combination of quality and quantity than the upper Cottonwoods, and Little Cottonwood gets the nod here because it is a bit snowier than Big Cottonwood.

Source: Secrets of the Greatest Snow on Earth
All sorts of crazy ideas exist concerning why it snows so much in the upper Cottonwoods, but the most obvious is almost always overlooked.  The terrain around the Cottonwoods forms an island of high terrain that is exposed to flow from nearly every direction.  Alta and Snowbird are well known for snow in northwesterly flow, but they almost always get something even when the flow is from other directions.

Source: Secrets of the Greatest Snow on Earth
This tremendous diversity of storms leads to the large annual snowfall totals and contrasts with other high areas of the Wasatch (e.g., Mt. Timpangos), which lie along linear ridges and have a narrower storm spectrum (e.g., predominantly southwesterly flow).

2. Mt. Baker, WA

Snowiest ski area in the world.  World record 1,140 inches recorded in the 1998/99 season.  Admittedly, Mt. Baker ski area isn't even the snowiest location in the region it sits in due to its low altitude, but an average snowfall of nearly 650 inches puts it at #2 on this list.

1. Snoqualmie Pass, WA

I'm guessing you didn't see it coming, but Snoqualmie Pass has a truly unique and remarkable microclimate.

The problem in the Cascades isn't moisture, it's temperature.  West of Snoqualmie Pass and along much of the western slopes of the Cascades, skiing isn't viable at 3000 feet elevation, the base elevation of the ski areas in Snoqualmie Pass.  If you drive to Snoqualmie Pass from Seattle, the snow line is often above 3000 feet, but turn the corner and enter the pass and you find a huge snowpack.

There's one main reason for this: cold easterly flow.  For much of the winter, the Cascades separate relatively mild marine air to the west from colder continental air to the east.  This cold air frequently pushes into Snoqualmie Pass, resulting in locally lower snow levels than found to the west.

The climate in Snoqualmie Pass is very similar to that in Stampede Pass, which is just to the south and has had an official weather station for many years.  If you look at a wind rose for Stampede Pass in January, you see a predominance of easterly flow.

Source: Steenburgh et al. (1997)
And this has a significant impact on temperature.  If you compare the mean temperature at Stampede Pass to Paradise ranger station on Mt. Rainier, it's actually colder from December to February, despite the lower elevation.  This is because Stampede Pass (and Snoqualmie) are frequently under the influence of cold, easterly flow, whereas Paradise is west of the Cascade crest and cutoff from the cold easterlies.

Source: Steenburgh et al. (1997)
If you could plug the low-elevation corridors that issue from eastern Washington to Stampede and Snoqualmie Pass, the snow climate would change dramatically, a much greater fraction of wintertime precipitation would fall as rain instead of snow, and one of the busiest ski areas in the United States would probably cease to exist or be barely viable.

Although the cold easterly flow is a remarkable refrigerator, it's not going to be able to hold off the inevitable as the planet warms in the coming years.  The snow climate of Snoqualmie Pass is one of the most vulnerable to global warming because of its low elevation and frequent snowfalls at temperatures near (and above) 0ÂșC.

Honorable Mentions:

Grand Targhee, WY (prolific snowfall on the windward side of the Tetons)
Crystal Mountain, WA (Mt. Rainier cloud and precipitation shadow)
Stevens Pass, WA (cold easterly flow)
Mission Ridge, WA (strongly shadowed)
Mt. Shasta Ski Park, Mt. Bachelor, Mt. Hood ski areas (large volcano influences)
Keystone, CO (strongly shadowed)
Steamboat, CO (large, low-density, seasonal snowfall for Colorado)
Whiteface, NY (really cold, but hey, at least it doesn't snow very much too)
Snowshoe, WV (snowy spot for mid-Atlantic region)

Add your $0.02 by commenting.  I've focussed on ski areas here for brevity, but feel free to think broadly (i.e., backcountry) and globally.

14 comments:

  1. For the mid-Atlantic, I think the Canaan Valley/Timberline/Whitegrass area is snowier than Snowshoe. As I understand it, Canaan Valley gets lake effect snow of the Great Lakes. The actual Canaan Valley is an unusually high large valley in that part of the world, probably contributing to colder temps too. Anyway, when I lived in that area, I always thought Canaan was a better bet than Snowshoe when looking to ski on natural snow rather than man made ice.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hokkaido Japan is fascinating with the "lake" effect it gets off the sea...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All of Japan is my favorite "microclimate"!

      Delete
  3. Snoqualmie Pass, number one?? Having skied there for one season, I thought all Snoqualmie was good for was the finest Cascade Concrete the PNW has to offer. I think Timberline deserves at least an honorable mention. Comparing Timberline's overall snow depth with that of Mt. Baker shows it is right there along with Mt. Baker as far as overall amount of snow. Now I am not too sure if Timberline just gets lots of storms for its high snow depth or because of Mt. Hood's microclimate and the way storms hit Mt. Hood coming off of the Pacific, but either way, worthy of an honorable mention. Plus, in my opinion, the Magic Mile is one of, if not the, most scenic lifts/runs in the PNW.

    Source: http://www.climate.washington.edu/snowdepth/

    P.S. Started reading your blog about a year ago, love it. First time commenting, just couldn't resist for this post being as I am a current PNW skier.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I certainly understand your snow quality perspectives as I skied 5 years at Alpental. I placed it at #1 not for that reason, but simply because I think it is the most anomalous local climatology in the ski business.

      Agree Mt. Hood has some great microclimates (and it was in the list, but I lumped it with the other volcanos).

      Delete
    2. Valid points and my bad, now I notice you did mention Mt. Hood. One more area, which I don't have statistics on but wanted to bring up, the backcountry on the western and eastern side of the Olympic Mountains in WA.

      Delete
    3. Granted Snoqualmie is a magnet for cascade concrete but when that cool westerly flow set up and the snow levels stayed nice and low, the powder could pile up there.

      Delete
  4. Not as sexy as snow microclimates, but Winter Park, CO has probably the most extreme temperature inversion microclimate I've ever experienced. It's pretty common to see a 40 to 50 degree temperature differential between the town of Fraser and the ski hill 10 miles away.

    Other fun ones: Eldora, CO (upslope feast or famine), Breckenridge, CO (continuously high N-S ridge that wind loads from most wind directions), Mauna Kea, HI (tropical snow!)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Cool. As soon as I saw Snoqualmie #1 I thought it was going to be completely based on the Puget Sound Convergence Zone. It's an oscillating area of heavy precipitation usually between Stevens to Snoqualmie in strong unstable W/NW flow. Very essential for those low ski spots.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love Snoqualmie Pass! My parents took me and my sisters up there a lot in the winter time and I can attest to the power of the easterly flow. It was magical turning the corner right before the pass and the rain would turn to snow right as you came up on the west summit exit. One bad side of the low level easterly flow was when warm storms would override a thin layer of cold air at the pass and then you would get freezing rain ruining the snow. But I have always had a fond place in my heart for Snoqualmie Pass and its wonderful microclimate.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bridger Bowl certainly deserves mention. Magical things happen under NW flow 71? inches in 24hrs in Dec 03.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yes you should have mentioned west coast of Japan. That "lake effect" generates January snowfall as high as Alta at Hakuba, and 70% higher than Alta at Niseko.

    And for US lake effect, surely Bohemia should rate higher than Snow Ridge since it gets more of the same kind of snow from a larger lake.

    Bridger Bowl does have an interesting microclimate in terms of independent weather. Sometimes it gets localized snow that others don't but sometimes it gets skunked on broad based weather systems. Overall snowfall is more than Big Sky but still far less than the Tetons.

    As far as Snoqualmie is concerned, presumably you have seen this:
    http://www.wsdot.com/winter/files/HistoricalSnowfallData1415season.pdf?v=16
    This is someplace we should be observing closely to see if warming temperatures are increasing the frequency of rain vs. snow. We might expect to see decreased snowfall between the 1970's and now but we do not. We do see decreased snowfall between the 1950's and 1970's, even though global temperatures did not rise then. Ratio of Snoqualmie to Raieir Paradise snowfall by time period:
    55-66 82.9%
    67-79 67.2%
    80-92 58.7%
    93-02 59.8%
    03-12 61.2%

    Could an urban heat island effect from Seattle's growth have affected Snoqualmie between the 50's and the 70's? Unfortunately when dealing with old snow data we always have to worry than data collection method at Snoqualmie might have changed.

    ReplyDelete