Monday, June 24, 2013

Big Moon Facts and Fictions

Minor edits have been made to this post to make some important clarifications as suggested by commenter Tommy T below.  

Moonset this morning over the Boulder Flatirons.  Sponsored by Bud Light.
I've been enjoying the hype and hyperbole over the Big Moon the past few days.  It's a wonder that we all haven't gone werewolf (well, perhaps some of you have).  There is both fact and fiction at play here.

The moon's orbit is elliptical and thus not quite circular.  Although the average distance to the moon is about 385,000 km, at perigee, when it is closest, it is about 365,000 km away, whereas at apogee, when it is farthest, it is about 405,000 km away.    

There is no doubt that this causes a change in the apparent size of the moon.  The solid angle subtended by the moon varies from about .56º at perigee to about .49º at apogee.  This does make the size of the moon seem to vary.  The moon subtends a larger solid angle and appears larger at perigee than it does at other points in it's orbital cycle.  

However, there is another trick at play here and that is something called the Moon Illusion.  When we observe moonrise, the moon often appears much larger than it does when it is near zenith (it's highest point in the sky).  This is not because the moon is closer at moonrise than at zenith, but instead because the presence of nearby objects affects our brain's interpretation of the scene.  The precise cause of this illusion is actually a subject of debate, but most of the photos I've seen of the Supermoon have this as an exaggerating factor.  

2 comments:

  1. Suggested edits:

    "There is no doubt that this causes a change in the APPARENT size of the moon. The solid angle subtended by the moon varies from about .56º at perigee to about .49º at apogee. This does make the size of the moon SEEM TO vary. Thus, it is a fact that the moon SUBTENDS A larger angle AT PERIGEE THAN it DOES at other points in it's orbital cycle."

    How to destroy the Moon Illusion: compare the size of the Moon when it is very near the horizon and looks quite large to the size of your thumbnail at arms length. Then, do the same thing when the Moon is high in the sky -- WOW! In both cases the size of the Moon is about the same as the size of thumb nail (Conveniently, people with big thumbs tend to have long arms, so most people have a thumbnail that subtends around 0.5 degrees of arc at arms lenth.) From then on, putting your thumb up beside the Moon when it is low on the horizon will instantly remove the Moon Illusion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tommy: Thanks for helping clarify a post made in haste prior to morning caffeination!

      Delete